Thursday, October 4, 2018

Understanding Conflict (II)




The inability or difficulty in both portraying one's own and understanding anothers 'truths' is one factor that contributes toward conflict, however, one must also consider communication barriers. What one says in order to convey a point may be perceived differently by the recipient. Yet again, this comes down to the differences in experiences and exposure of both individuals and in some cases, could even affect the issue in a positive manner.
Thus far, the focus of this post has been prominently based on the incompatible internal differences of two parties – however, there are also external factors that contribute to conflict in subtle ways. In 1971, Prof. Albert Mehrabian of UCLA argued that only 7% of a message was derived from words, while 38% came from intonation, with the remaining 55% from facial expression or body language. Applying that thought to today's societal norms, one can begin to see how communication had been simplified with the rise of the internet, smartphones and social networking. At best, video calling theoretically covers all three bases, but the fact is that the most used method would be through texting. Using this medium, everything apart from the statement (not to be confused with the message that the statement is attempting to accurately establish) is essentially removed from the understanding of what communication is.
Interpersonal conflict as a whole stems from not being able to understand a person's character and at the same time, not being able to portray one's own with accuracy. The actions, more times than not, will not outweigh the principles, and will function at most as a catalyst, but not as the cause of a conflict.  

In short, conflict can easily arise from ineffective communication skills. At Mediate2Resolve Online, we offer professional mediation services for a host of situations, ranging from disputes in the workplace to domestic disagreements with a partner. Additionally, we offer workshops for those looking to improve on their communication skills. Please click here to be taken to our website and explore our full range of services and workshops.


Thursday, September 27, 2018

Understanding Conflict (I)




The world was shaped through the existence of conflict – conflict of wants and needs, beliefs and ethics, conflict as a rite of passage and/or tradition, conflict as a perceived necessity to ensure the continuity of one as an individual, society or nation. Inversely, the world was also shaped by the actions taken to address, avoid and/or remedy conflict, from which arises a plethora of wants for better lives, security, opportunity and mutual gain. Conflict, to a certain degree, is a natural occurrence that while mostly unsavoury, can even be viewed as a means and therefore a necessity towards a greater understanding between two parties.

While conflict exists on any and all degrees, the focus of this post will be on the occurrence of it in everyday life. At an interpersonal level, conflict can arise from hardship, clashes in approach, views on certain trigger subjects (religion and politics come to mind), betrayal between friends or partners, even as a result from nothing else but emotional conditioning. When addressing conflict, people tend to focus on the defining factors of that specific instance rather than view conflict as a self contained concept. Humans, being the highly complex creatures that we are, are quick to forget that others live a life just as emotionally deep and rich as we do. The result of this is the subconscious habit of underestimating how much peoples views are framed around experiences that we have not had, or the anecdotes they may have heard, or even how effective that anecdote might be depending on who provided it and if that person is held in high regard.

Conflict is solidified because two parties cannot understand (or can, but aren't willing to admit) that their solution to or the framework of the subject is only based on the experiences they have had, and the 'truths' they had come to adopt on a matter as a result of that. Take for example, two men who are both experiencing the loss of a family member. In their grieving they come to associate things with death differently and eventually, accept those understandings as their 'truths' on the matter. The reason why conflict tends to be a downward spiral is that humans are so self absorbed that it is just easier and more natural to base things on the truths one has experienced rather than process a train of thought in a completely foreign framing (even then, the adoption of which is subjected to the person's biases).
Of course, it would be impossible to completely rid the world of conflict. However, at Mediate2Resolve Online, we offer professional mediation services for a host of situations, ranging from disagreements with a spouse or disputes with a colleague at work. Please click here to be taken to our website and explore our full range of services and workshops.


Thursday, September 20, 2018

Mediation – With One's Self Before One Another (II)




Being a process that involves two or more parties and a neutral third party, how can mediation apply to oneself? The answer is in its approach – mediation takes time in listening to both sides of a conflict. The outcome isn't skewered by bias and the third party ultimately has no say in your decision, allowing you to adopt a more unencumbered approach to resolving the situation. This is admittedly something most of us will have trouble with when it comes to ourselves – dispelling bias. It's simple to fall into the misguided understanding that if for example you find a certain personality trait repellent, the trait surely must be inherently “bad”. In reality, the mental framework that we have spent a lifetime putting together on any one thing or subject only makes resolution more difficult by closing ourselves off to a different perspective.

This is where the mediation process employs a third party – by introducing a component in the process that will not benefit in any way, thus eliminating any wants or bias that may stem from those wants. In order to resolve conflict within oneself, one must first detach his wants from his actions and decide if they are of a proportionate degree, and whether or not they are worth the morals and values you are either upholding or pushing aside.

The point of this is to come out of the process clearer about what you want and how you want to achieve it, while gauging what you're willing to sacrifice and who you're willing to hurt (be it yourself or someone else) and whether or not it is objectively 'worth' it. Mediation has proven effective because it does not focus on the truth or fault of an instance and those involved, but rather how the problem can be remedied. One cannot hope to resolve a conflict with someone if one is unsure of what he wants – and while everyone may handle it differently, this has proven effective not only in assessing oneself, but in providing a sense of becoming while doing so.
Of course, conflict resolution involves a wide range of soft skills that not everyone may possess. At Mediate2Resolve Online, we offer professional mediation services for a host of situations, ranging from disputes with a colleague to disagreements with a partner. Please click here to be taken to our website and explore our full range of services and workshops.


Thursday, September 13, 2018

Mediation – With One's Self Before One Another (I)





Often times life has a peculiar way of throwing obstacles at us – some have clear cut solutions while others may fall into more of a 'blurred line' category. The former may be the everyday errand. Answers are relatively simple. The latter, however, tends to be (or appear) more complex in its nature purely because not only does it exist as a problem in itself, it also serves as an avenue for emotions, perspectives, values and morals to which are subjected to the individual's understanding of the world. Naturally, incompatibility between perspectives and goals arise and from this – disputes are born. This tend to boil down to conflicting wants of two or more parties and the inability/lack of will to realise their individual goals partially as to allow for all parties to walk away with something.

Everybody handles, views and values confrontation differently, but in general it is an exchange that often results in negative feelings towards the other party. Reconciliation, the thing the comes next (or at least a ways down the road), is a whole lot more beautiful but ironically cannot exist without the former – that statement isn't true the other way round though. In the posts to come this will be covered with more depth but for today, lets delve instead into mediating conflict within yourself before attempting to resolve an issue with another person.

For those not already familiar with it, mediation is an approach in which parties enter in a negotiation that is facilitated by a neutral third party and is categorised as a means of alternative dispute resolution (ADR). Mediation, however, is a voluntary process that involves the participants reaching a mutually favourable outcome that they decide is fair – this in my opinion can be more effective than arbitration, where decision making involves the third party and in result, may not yield the same extent of satisfaction. This puts the parties involved at risk of forced closure, thus not really tackling the issue at a grassroots level. At Mediate2Resolve Online, we offer professional mediation services for a host of situations, ranging from disputes with a boss or co-worker, to miscommunications at home. Please click here to be taken to our website and explore our full range of services and workshops.



Monday, August 20, 2018

Essential Communication & Negotiation Skills for Conflict Resolution

Come join our 1 day fun-filled workshop on 22nd November 2018 whereby you will learn the tools of effective communication for your everyday personal and professional life!  It will be held at the Faculty of Law, University of Malaya . Contact Yana or Nurin at umcors.events@um.edu.my or call 03-79676579.


Here are the full day programme details -

Search for @mediate2resolveonline on Facebook!

Sunday, September 3, 2017

Comparison between Arabic and Malay Customary Dispute Resolution Methods



In Arab culture, honour is a very important value, being a function of tribal identity: thus conflict arises simply when there is a threat to honour. Bedouin life was harsh and nomadic, violent raids and counter-raids upon neighbouring tribes being an acceptable mode of gaining food and other needs. Bedouin values thus emphasize tribal cohesion and loyalties, and threats to the honour of an individual, is accordingly a threat to the honour of  the tribe. Dishonour to a member (perhaps by the capture of a wife or daughter) or death caused to an individual can conflagrate to tribal conflict giving rise to endless cycles of vengeance. Survival of the tribe depends on the timely resolution of disputes and plenty of exhortations to this end appear in the Quran[1]. Family disputes, being the core of tribal life, are particularly addressed[2]. Even Arabic townspeople were tribal in social structure, thus the cohesion and survival of tribe remains a priority. Traditional Middle Eastern dispute resolution mechanisms has the centrifugal force revenge-forgiveness.
There appears to be several techniques commonly used in Arabic culture, including counseling (nasihah), conciliation (sulh), arbitration (tahkim) or mediation/intervention (wasaata, tawasut, alshafaa, aljaryu, husnu al-sifara). The outcome becomes a concluded contract.
The process of sulh or conciliation is often used in cases of wrongful death claims, as retribution in terms of the life of the perpetrator is often the demanded recompense. Often, the family of the guilty party would initiate the process for fear of retribution. The appointment of a third party consisting of a panel of trusted elders (jaha) signals a declaration of temporary truce (hudna) usually accompanied by a token payment of good faith (arwa). Through shuttle diplomacy (whereby the conflicting families do not meet), a series of concessions and trade-offs are obtained, ending in the payment of blood-money (diya in cases involving death, or taawir in other cases) in a public ceremony of musalaha involving a ritual of seeking and giving forgiveness.
The process of tahkim might take the form of conflicting parties seeking an opinion from a respected legal scholar (mufti) who would engage in a process of in-depth research to find the applicable legal rules on the subject. The opinion is given, and although not binding, will be given considerable weight.
The process of wasaata is describes as “walking between disputants” whereby the intervenor in a non-binding procedure seeks an amicable settlement by proposing solutions to the parties.

Malays, by contrast, were sedentary farmers and fisher-folk who were governed by adat on a day to day basis. There are two sets of adat (custom) followed by traditional Malay communities: adat pepatih (a matrilineal custom) and adat temenggong (a patrilineal custom). Adat temenggong is modified through the influence of Islamic law to the extent that it almost mirrors Islamic law in norms and administration.
 In general, in traditional Malay society, people who allow a conflict to reach a destructive stage are considered anti-social, the emphasis being on familial and community peace and harmony. The identity of the Malay is intricately linked to  “adat” that imposes very strict social rules and etiquette to the conduct and language of the person.  In Malay literature, there is no concept of law as we know it today, but “adat” is supreme, laying down the rules for social engagement. At community level, harmony and togetherness are the most important values, therefore resolutions affecting community are induced by the concept of selaras (unanimity).
At the personal level, adat ensures the observance of dignity and  “muka” (face) whereby any affront to the person’s face will bring deep shame and inflict a wound to the Malay psyche. Since raised voices, anger and harsh words (affecting the harmony of the environment) are deemed impolite, the Malay would internalize the offense giving rise to “amok” in some rare cases, whereby the person lashes out in a rampage of rage and anger, attacking and killing anyone in his way.
Since face is important, Malays prefer not to publicise disputes, turning to the village headman (ketua kampong), or other respected figures within the community such as the imam of the mosque or an elder within the family. The 3rd party would often give advise to the parties and parties would accept the advise to achieve peace so that harmonious relationships can be restored. Parties may be asked to “beralah” (give way) whereby the older would give in to the younger on the grounds of immaturity, or conversely “bagi muka” (give face) to the elder by the younger. Almost all disputes are settled in this manner, most times with simmering resentments on the part of the party forced to give the concession. Once a year, on the Eid everyone asks others for forgiveness for intended or unintended offences, ostensibly clearing the slate for the next year.
Where a conflict is more intractable, it would be escalated to the chieftain or escalated to the Sultan, being the final arbiter of all things in the territory. The Sultan’s mythical divine qualities result in unquestioning obedience by the abject subject, for fear of the curse of the Sultan’s daulat (or majestic powers) being visited upon the person or family of the disputant. 
Although the modern Malay is less constrained by adat as his ancestors were, nevertheless the reluctance to wash dirty linen in public and the upholding of face is important. Disputes are therefore either brushed under the carpet or parties are forced to reconcile through concessions for the sake of harmony. It is rare that a “win-win” outcome would emerge. Otherwise, the modern Malaysian would turn to modern judicial institutions in seek of the upholding of their "rights", something introduced by the common law.
In terms of pre-legal action, it would seem that the modern Western style mediation (in particular facilitative mediation) is suitable to modern Malaysians to whom private and confidential methods would be more suitable in the preservation of "face" as compared to Arab values emphasising on the public and upholding of honour.





[1] Al Quran verses 8:1, 4:35, 4:59, 4:65, 4:114, 49:9-10
[2] Al Quran verses 4:128, 5:2

Monday, June 19, 2017

Business Diplomacy: Resolving Disputes Through Mediation


Qatar is seeking mediation with its Arab neighbors to resolve the current Middle East conflict. The fracas began when Saudi Arabia, the UAE, Bahrain and Egypt cut diplomatic ties and shut their borders to Qatar on allegations of Qatari support for terrorist organizations. The source of the conflict was purportedly due to implanted false reporting in Qatari news by nefarious agents of another country.

In the Arabic culture, the use of “sulha” or “sulh” (similar to the mediation-arbitration of the West) is common. This method employs a third party committee (“jaha”) to effect shuttle diplomacy and proxy discussions between disputing parties. Normally, sulha is used to resolve victim-offender conflict that might threaten to tilt two families, and ultimately two clans or tribes into open conflict.

The utilization of mediation as a customary practice is widespread amongst native communities worldwide, and considered as the primary dispute resolution method in these societies. Resorting to courts and the litigation system is a 20th century phenomenon introduced by colonial powers. Notwithstanding, mediation is not an alternative but as demonstrated in the case of Qatar and its neighbors, a centuries old go-to tool in diplomacy. After all, before Qatar and its neighbours became states five decades ago, they were the tribes Al Thani, Al Khalifa, Al Sabah and Al Saud. 

So, why shouldn’t businesses too resort to this form of diplomacy in settling business disputes? Especially in societies where values such as face, honor, reputation and harmony are prized over profits and money. When direct negotiation between parties are deadlocked, mediation is useful for the following reasons:-

·     A mediator can invite each side to take a step towards one another, which for ego or organizational reasons, they could previously not do.
·     He or she can stimulate creativity on how to arrive at a mutually beneficial deal or how to by-pass the deadlock.
·     In private sessions, the mediator would allow each party to confide what they would otherwise not be able to express in the presence of the other party for fear of damaging bargaining leverage, and explore with the mediator any changes in their own position.
·     The mediator can invite both parties to express themselves and listen to both sides without anger, at the same time framing the views for understanding and acknowledgement.
·     The parties can explore compromise solutions or positions that either party alone would be afraid to propose.

As an alternative dispute resolution method to the traditional litigious framework, mediation brings too much value and efficacy to businesses to ignore. It saves costs, time and energy and allows executives to concentrate on what is important – building the business and making money.

Consult our experienced business mediators at www.mediate2resolveonline.com to explore more.